SCALPED– I bet Italians sorta hate the Sopranos, too

 <-- from 

   Some of those who want forces/are the same that burn crosses...

-Rage Against the Machine

I’ve been thinking seriously about extending my small nugget of comic book scholarship (see long, rambling Soviet Superman paper…) into the ever growing circle of my Native studies scholarship. My first instinct was to write about the Marvel comics character Warpath (a hyper-violent Native warrior with mutant strength and a pair of almost “magical” knives who is currently carving up people in a story called “The Mesiah Complex”), but as I looked over some of the things out there to analyze, I came across the Vertigo title SCALPED.

If you follow the link above, you’ll see a rather scathing review of the title (the image is a piece of art from the series). I cannot, currently, launch a direct counterargument because I have only read one issue (I’m going to order the trade paperbacks from Amazon, so look for more on this). I can attest to seeing exactly what the creators claim is in the first issue, though: it looks like the Sopranos on a reservation. It’s gritty, and sadistic, and quite frankly gripping.

My commentary here is a response to the general idea expressed by the commentary from the critic at I don’t particularly disagree with his interpretation/response; the whole idea of reviewing and critiquing is to say what you feel. But I think, based on the exchange depicted on the page, there is a problem that I sort of fear as I move into Native/Indigenous studies: why should ANY depiction of Native peoples be considered a reflection on ALL Native peoples?

I have twice (or maybe thrice) made the comparison to the Sopranos here. I think that’s apt. I personally LOVED the Sopranos (even the ending that bothered so many fans that the complaints crashed HBO’s website three times the night it aired). I found most of the characters compelling, and while the situations were gritty, sometimes way-over-the-top, and certainly less-than-positive depictions of Italian Americans, the show pushed artistic bounds and entertained while making an intricate, engaging argument.

Other than within the program (through the Italian American character who plays the otherwise forgettable therapist who sees Dr. Melphi, Tony Soprano’s therapist), there is very little backlash from the Italian American community about the Sopranos. It is, after all, a mafia TV show, following the same sort of genre fiction as Puzo’s Godfather or movies like Goodfellas. It is quite obvious that Tony Soprano isn’t meant to be “every Italian-American man,” though at times it seems like he’s the American everyman (in fact the last episode’s title “Made in America” makes perhaps the most clever wordplay of the series, pointing out that Tony and his crew are a decidedly American development as “made” men).  The stories that David Chase and his crew of writers crafted for the Sopranos draw from a specific community, and raise visibility of that community, but they are not meant to stand in as an ubersignifier, as it were.

And I am sure that someone, somewhere, would lodge the complaint that I am misrepresenting the complaints lodged against the Sopranos; there were no doubt small scale things. But the initial fervor that was anticipated when the show was first discussed (before it had ever aired) didn’t result in the wide-scale criticism. And to be fair, the complaint I linked here is one of the few entirely anti-SCALPED commentaries I’ve seen. If one were doing something other than a thought exercise (as I reveal my own research ethics) she’d want to do this sort of research. If I’m misrepresenting either situation, my apologies.

But my concern is that as a Native creator, the reviewer from BlueCorn was just too hard on SCALPED early on. I’ve done extensive research on Leonard Peltier, and as such I know that there has, indeed, been a spotlight on violence involving reservation land and policies. I also know, as a fan of both comic books and crime dramas that the genre demands a certain handling of violence and “grit” as I’m going to call it right now. In that sense, what *I* saw in the first issue of SCALPED was a cabal of tribal criminals acting like criminals.


I would argue that to craft SCALPED any other way would be wrong. There’s no reason to make a Native criminal somehow noble, and in fact I think that would do harm to popular understanding of what life on the reservation is like. So if the other argument, I assume, would be to NOT write about criminals on a reservation, corrupt casino owners in a violent, violent world. And I guess, in some ways, as a mixed-blood Cherokee, I can see that. But I don’t “get” it as a scholar.

I don’t think we should ever treat some segment of the population as “off limits” as fodder for popular culture just because we’re afraid that trying to depict something stylized but realistic using elements of that culture. If we do that, we essentially say “popular culture has to be about white people,” and that’s one of the biggest criticisms of the status quo on TV, in comic books, in movies, etc. 

Until we can accept that any of us can be good or bad, and as such any of us can be depicted as good or bad, I don’t know if we’re really making progress or just playing “nice” with each other.


2 Responses to SCALPED– I bet Italians sorta hate the Sopranos, too

  1. Rob Schmidt says:

    Interesting commentary. Naturally, I don’t agree. I’ll post a response and let you know when it’s available.

    I’ve linked to several positive and negative reviews on my Scalped page ( Check ’em out. Many people don’t agree with me…but I’ve yet to hear a persuasive argument.

    I’d like to see your critique of Warpath. Send it to me and I’ll publish it. Or post it here and I’ll link to it.

    Incidentally, I’m not a Native creator, since I’m a WASP with no Indian blood.


  2. alexa325 says:

    Sorry to have mis-identified you as Native, Rob (sloppy research on my part), but thanks for your response. I’ll feel more comfortable defending the series, or panning it, when I’ve read more (I’m trying to let my mind wander a little as I blog, but it’s sort of bad scholarship for me to attempt to base my view on one single issue).

    I’m going to work up my Warpath critique, hopefully by next week, then I’ll post it. I think he has to be viewed in a slightly different way because he’s much more obviously “fictional” (though many would argue that fiction is just fiction; I tend to believe the genre a fictional character exists within has dramatic power in how he or she is received).

    I took a quick look at a few of the reviews linked from your site. I think there’s one step I’m not willing to make, yet, that might somewhat stifle our discussion: I don’t know if I think SCALPED is actually a good comic/story. I liked the first issue, but I also have to admit to liking the first few episodes of DESPERATE HOUSEWIVES, and that didn’t turn out being enjoyable at all in the end. I do maintain, however, that we have to be careful, as a culture, not to have a gut reaction to the treatment of “othered” populations.

    I did some work a few years ago on Grand Theft Auto; San Andreas, and one of the big, big critiques (beyond the obvious “this game is so violent” fervor) was that the protagonist was a poor reflection of African American males. On the one hand, yes, that’s an obvious statement (just as one could make the statement that Denzel Washington’s character in TRAINING DAY was a poor reflection on African American males, even as Washington himself is a profoundly positive role-model), but in a much larger sense it attempted to lodge the argument that when looking at an “other,” a single case somehow represents the whole, as if the fact that this character was a certain color suddenly commented on everyone that was that color. The same argument wasn’t made for the white protagonist of GTA:III.

    It reminds me of a Chris Rock joke:

    “Everyone talks about black-on-black crime, but you never hear them talk about white-on-white crime. Don’t they call that war?”

    As a scholar, I want to push for recognition of my Cherokee culture (and for a seat at “the table” as it were), but I feel like that means that on some level we need to be part of the overall popular landscape. It would be nicer, obviously, to be depicted as the hero than the villain, but there are bad people of every race, gender and worldview (sadly, perhaps).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: